Housing Communities • Knowledge Base

Housing community rules in Poland: what they can and can’t cover

The rules of a housing community, sometimes referred to as “house rules” or “rules of operation of a housing community”, are the basic document organising the rules of operation for residents in a multi-unit building in Poland. Although the Polish Act on the Ownership of Premises does not impose an obligation on housing communities to adopt such regulations, in practice many communities adopt them, rightly recognising that they are an effective legal tool for increasing order, safety and the efficient functioning of the housing community within the building. The main purpose of the rules and regulations is therefore to ensure harmonious neighbourly relations and to prevent disputes between flat owners in the future.

However, our experience shows that, in many cases, in Poland housing community management boards and flat owners are not fully aware that, in accordance with the Polish Act on the Ownership of Premises, the housing community regulations may only contain provisions that are consistent with the law, including Article 13(1) of the Polish Act on the Ownership of Premises, and may not infringe on the property rights of individual flat owners in Poland. In practice, this means, among other things, that the regulations cannot modify the statutory rights and obligations of owners, impose additional financial burdens on them, restrict the use of the premises beyond the scope of orderly standards, or interfere with elements that can only be regulated by resolution.

In this publication, we explain what can (and what absolutely cannot) be regulated by the rules of a housing community.

What are the rules and regulations of a housing community?

Pursuant to Article 13(1) of the Polish Act on the Ownership of Premises, the owner bears the expenses related to the maintenance of their premises, is obliged to maintain their premises in proper condition, observe house rules, contribute to the management costs related to the maintenance of the common property, use it in a manner that does not hinder its use by other co-owners, and cooperate with them in protecting the common good. It is this provision that entitles housing communities to adopt house rules, also known as the rules of operation of a housing community.

The rules of the housing community generally supplement and clarify the provisions of the Act on the Ownership of Premises. Their purpose is to define and clarify the rules for the functioning of the common property and the organisation of the residents’ life within the building. Importantly, the document is not a local law, but an internal document binding on all owners of premises in the property (residential and commercial) and persons using the property.

A practical example from Polish case law:

“It is difficult to require absolute precision from house rules, which is often hard to find in statutory regulations. Their purpose is to regulate neighbourly relations and eliminate future conflicts. They are created not by lawyers, but by property owners who want to protect the common property and mutual respect for the rights of residents.” (judgment of the Polish Court of Appeal in Krakow, 1st Civil Division, of 17 May 2018, ref. no. I ACa 1282/17)

What can be regulated by the rules of a housing community?

The scope of housing community rules in Poland is often disputed. This is because property owners often try to influence the behaviour of individual residents by means of ‘orderly’ resolutions, while the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises and the Civil Code very precisely define the limits of the competences of housing communities.

The starting point is management of the common property and the statutory duty to observe house rules. Regulations may clarify those duties, including conduct within units affecting neighbours or common property. This does not give the community a general power to determine the purpose or use of private units.

The regulations may, however, specify in detail:

  • the manner of using common areas such as staircases, corridors, lifts, basements and storage rooms, drying rooms, pram storage rooms, bicycle storage rooms, green areas, patios, playgrounds, technical rooms, parking spaces (if assigned to specific premises). In practice, owners may, for example, adopt regulations prohibiting the leaving of private belongings in corridors due to fire safety regulations, establish rules for parking in common areas or specify the hours of use of sports fields and playgrounds,

  • introduce rules regarding quiet hours, renovation work, waste segregation, obligations to maintain balconies in proper condition, rules for storing bicycles, prams or building materials,

  • regulate the rules of coexistence between residents, for example: the obligation to clean up after pets, guidelines for walking dogs on the premises, a ban on disruptive or unsafe behaviour, and therefore any issues that may contribute to good coexistence between residents, provided that they do not violate the property rights of the premises,

  • specify the rules for the use of equipment and installations that interfere with the common property, for example: air conditioners, satellite dishes, awnings, security grilles, advertisements and signs. The community may require owners of premises to obtain consent for the installation of such equipment,

  • determine the manner in which third parties may use the property, including rules for admitting renovation crews, opening hours for gates or wickets, and methods for providing keys or remote controls.

The right of the housing community to enforce the compulsory sale of a flat

In the event of persistent violation of the rules of order by the owner of the premises (or their tenants), the housing community may file a lawsuit in court, citing Article 16(1) of the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises. According to this provision, if the owner of the premises:

  • grossly or persistently violates the applicable house rules, or
  • through inappropriate conduct, makes the use of other premises or common areas burdensome, or through persistent violations of house rules or other serious misconduct by the owner,

A housing community may seek a compulsory sale under Article 16(1), following the required owners’ resolution. Gross or persistent breaches of house rules are alternative characteristics and need not occur together. A single but gross incident cannot be excluded categorically. The court assesses the statutory grounds, seriousness of the conduct and proportionality of this far-reaching remedy.

What can’t be covered by the housing community rules?

  • The rules can’t interfere with the flat owner’s right to own the place

House rules cannot create unauthorised restrictions on ownership or freely determine the use of a private unit. They may nevertheless clarify order and conduct affecting neighbours or common property within the limits of Article 13(1). For example, the following blanket restrictions, lacking a statutory basis, are impermissible:

  • prohibiting short-term rental of residential premises,
  • prohibiting business activity in the premises,
  • imposing an obligation to obtain the consent of the housing community for renovations carried out inside the premises,
  • prohibiting the keeping of animals in the premises,
  • setting visiting hours in the premises,
  • specifying noise levels inside the premises (only general regulations, e.g. the Polish Code of Petty Offences, may be referred to).

A practical example from Polish case law:

“The owners of premises may not therefore adopt any resolutions that would interfere with the rights of separate ownership of premises, impose obligations on the owners of premises other than those resulting from the Act on the Ownership of Premises, or modify the general rules of civil liability of their members contrary to the provisions of law. This is undoubtedly the nature of the provisions of the contested house rules concerning the liability of the owner of a unit for the behaviour of persons using the premises with his knowledge, the liability of the owner of a unit for such persons’ compliance with the rules and his obligation to familiarise such persons with the rules, liability for any damage caused by children, the obligation to report any faults to the community manager, the prohibition on conducting business activities in residential premises without the consent of the manager, the prohibition on installing electrical outlets for personal use in basements and conducting service or production activities there without the consent of the community, and finally, the prohibition on opening stairwell doors with an intercom to strangers” (judgment of the Polish Regional Court in Łódź, 2nd Civil Division, of 2 September 2021, ref. no. II C 2438/20).

  • The regulations cannot impose financial penalties for violations

The housing community may not introduce ‘financial’, “disciplinary” or ‘regulatory’ penalties, fines or additional fees in the regulations, even if their sole purpose is to ensure compliance with the regulations by maintaining order or preventing damage. Case law indicates that the provisions of the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises do not give communities the right to issue authoritative instructions to owners, as the community is not an administrative body, but only an entity managing common property.

This prohibition also covers penalties and additional charges imposed to compel the repayment of arrears. We explain in greater detail what a housing community may and may not do in relation to an owner in arrears.

Therefore, if a housing community adopts a resolution that implements a mechanism of financial penalties for members of the housing community for any violation of the rules, each owner has the right to appeal against it in court on the basis of Article 25 of the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises, according to which the owner of a unit may appeal against a resolution in court on the grounds that it is inconsistent with the law or the agreement between the owners of the premises, or if it violates the principles of proper management of the common property or otherwise violates his interests.

A practical example from Polish case law:

“No provision of law allows a Housing Community to make declarations of will of an authoritative nature, which individual owners would be obliged to comply with. There are no grounds for the Housing Community to adopt preventive regulations aimed at preventing possible threats or damage” (judgment of the Polish Court of Appeal in Warsaw, 1st Civil Division, of 20 January 2014, ref. no. I ACa 1394/13).

  • The regulations cannot modify the rules resulting from the Act on the Ownership of Premises

Community rules cannot change the statutory rules on voting, shares or the management board’s powers. Matters governed by mandatory provisions of the Act on the Ownership of Premises cannot be altered by internal regulations.

A practical example from Polish case law:

“It should therefore be generally agreed with the defendant that, whether by way of a notarial deed or a subsequent resolution recorded by a notary public, the owners are free to decide on the manner of managing the common property, provided that the adopted rules do not conflict with the Act on the Ownership of Premises and the exceptions provided for therein, which should not be interpreted broadly” (judgment of the Polish Court of Appeal in Szczecin, 1st Civil Division, of 20 October 2011, ref. no. I ACa 526/11).

How can a housing community adopt housing community regulations?

The rules and regulations of a housing community are adopted by way of a resolution of the owners of the premises. This resolution may be adopted at a meeting of owners, by individual collection of votes or in a mixed form (partly at a community meeting, partly outside it). A simple majority of shares in the property is required to adopt the rules and regulations.

Of course, as a rule, the draft rules are prepared by the community’s management board or the administrator acting on the basis of a management agreement, in practice based on the recommendation of the housing community’s legal representative.

It is also good practice to make the draft rules available to the owners of premises in advance, in a manner that allows them to familiarise themselves with its content before voting.

As the rules and regulations are an internal document of the community, they do not need to be submitted to any authority or formally registered. It is sufficient to adopt a resolution.

Can a resolution of a Polish housing community to adopt the rules and regulations of the housing community be challenged?

Yes, and in practice this happens quite often in Poland. If the resolution to adopt the rules violates the law, the principles of social coexistence or in any way harms the interests of the flat owner, in accordance with the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises, each flat owner has the right to bring a court action to challenge it.

Rules that exceed the community’s statutory competence or unlawfully restrict use of a private unit may justify challenging the resolution. A distinction must be made between such restrictions and lawful rules concerning conduct affecting neighbours or common property, consistent with the owner’s statutory duties.

In proceedings concerning the repeal of housing community regulations, the court assesses not only the content of the regulations, but also the procedure for adopting the resolution. Therefore, a resolution may be repealed for both substantive and formal reasons (e.g. lack of the required majority of shares, errors in counting votes, incorrect notification of the meeting).

Consequently, careful preparation of the draft rules and proper conduct of the vote are crucial for their validity.

A practical example from Polish case law:

“In accordance with the house rules: parking of motor vehicles is only permitted in designated areas. Parking on pavements, access roads and lawns is prohibited. In the event of parking outside the designated area, penalties will be imposed in the form of wheel clamping or towing to a paid secure car park at the expense of the owner of the incorrectly parked car. No provision grants such a right to a housing community or other natural or legal persons hired by them, in particular, Article 13 of the Act on the Ownership of Premises does not grant such a right. The housing community’s independent granting of such a right to itself must therefore be considered contrary to the law, i.e. the Constitution of the Republic of Poland. In the opinion of the Polish Court of Appeal, there is no doubt that by parking on the premises of the community outside the designated areas in a manner that hinders the use of the common property by other co-owners, the claimant violates the rules provided for in Article 13 of the Act on the Ownership of Premises, but this does not justify the application of such severe sanctions against him or anyone else” (judgment of the Polish Court of Appeal in Warsaw, 6th Civil Division, of 27 May 2009, ref. no. VI ACa 1124/08)

Summary

The rules and regulations of a housing community in Poland are an important organisational tool which, if properly constructed, can increase safety, comfort and predictability in the functioning of owners of premises in a multi-unit building. However, it is important that the rules and regulations of a housing community must remain within the limits set by the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises and generally applicable law.

House rules should concern management of the common property and lawful standards of order, including conduct within units insofar as it affects neighbours or common property. They cannot arbitrarily determine use of private units, create disciplinary fines or alter mandatory statutory duties and powers. Lawful financial obligations require their proper legal basis and procedure.

Well-prepared rules and regulations help to avoid neighbourly conflicts, specify the rules for the use of common areas and raise the standard of property management. However, it is worth remembering that each provision of the rules and regulations should be verified for compliance with the law and current case law. This may be assessed in an audit of a homeowners’ association and the activities of its board. Otherwise, the community runs the risk of having the resolution overturned by the Polish court.

How we can help with housing community regulations in Poland

If a housing community in Poland wants to adopt or amend housing community regulations or house rules, we can help prepare a document that organises the use of the common property while not excessively interfering with the ownership rights of unit owners.

In particular, we assist with:

  • preparing or reviewing housing community regulations in Poland and internal house rules,
  • assessing which matters may be effectively regulated in the rules and which require a separate housing community resolution or cannot be regulated by the community at all,
  • preparing rules for the use of common parts of the property, including staircases, corridors, lifts, garages, parking spaces, green areas and technical rooms,
  • reviewing provisions concerning quiet hours, renovation works, storage of items in common areas, waste segregation, pets, advertisements, signs, air-conditioning units and antennas,
  • verifying whether the regulations do not infringe the rights of unit owners, impose impermissible financial obligations or interfere with the use of individual units beyond the limits of Polish law,
  • preparing a draft resolution on adopting or amending housing community regulations and documents required for voting,
  • representing a housing community or a unit owner in disputes concerning challenging a resolution on housing community regulations.

We help prepare housing community regulations in Poland in a practical manner, compliant with the Polish Act on Ownership of Premises and safe from the perspective of future disputes. We analyse the needs of the specific property, previous issues between residents, existing resolutions, the way common areas are used and the risk of the regulations being challenged by unit owners.

FAQ

Until the rules of the housing community are repealed by a Polish court, they remain in force. If the owner considers them to be unlawful, they should bring an action to repeal the resolution. The action may (and should) also include a request to secure the claim by suspending the implementation of the resolution until the court case is concluded. Thanks to this, the owner will not be obliged to apply the disputed rules during the proceedings, and the community will not be able to enforce its provisions.

No. Renovation carried out within the boundaries of the flat, i.e. one that does not affect the common areas, including the structure of the building or installations, does not require the consent of the community. Consequently, the rules cannot impose such obligations on flat owners.

In the common areas of a building located on the property, the housing community may prohibit the installation of cameras or monitoring, as this concerns the use of common property. However, it does not have this right within the premises, unless the camera records common areas or someone else’s property without consent.

Yes, it can, because the stairwell is a common area of the property. The community may prohibit leaving items there if they obstruct passage or pose a fire hazard. The housing community may also specify rules for using the pram and bicycle storage rooms.

Yes, the housing community may prohibit barbecuing, as such activities may pose a fire hazard and cause nuisance and interfere with the use of common areas by other owners. The ban may, for example, apply to the patio or green area belonging to the community.

Yes. Tenants are required to comply with the rules of the community in the same way as the owners of the premises they occupy.

About the Author

Mateusz Radomyski, LLB, LL.M

Solicitor and managing partner of Verdict Partners Law Firm. He specialises in civil, criminal, and real estate matters, providing legal services to individual and business clients, including foreigners in Poland.